If most of your traditions are in the ceremony, and you want a short ceremony... and if you want to have SOME tradition... maybe you could each pick your ONE favorite tradition and just do that... or make up YOUR OWN new tradition to pass on to your kids or something.
As for the cookie table:
It is a tradition passed down by imigrant families who could not afford to provide a cake for the wedding. Instead, the brides family would bring cookies to be the "something sweet". Now-a-days in our neck of the woods, the cookie table is USUALLY laid out and eaten with the hors d'ouvers (which I personally think is silly, but whatever). I've been to weddings in other "necks" where boxes are provided for people to take cookies home in - this is what we're gonna do instead of favors (though the cookies will be laid out in advance if people want to much).
For our wedding, since I don't have any family locally, FH's aunt have all offered to bake for me

And we'll have a cake in addition to make my family happy.